12 Ways to Boost Membership Retention

Membership organisations of all kinds from professional associations to trade bodies face the familiar challenge of keeping members. Attracting new members feels exciting but the real driver of sustainable growth is membership retention. Retaining existing members is more cost-effective, builds loyalty, and creates long term value.

So, how do you turn retention into your engine of growth? The short answer: by giving consistent value to members. A strong retention rate depends on consistency in communication, benefits, and the overall member experience. When members feel recognised, supported, and engaged, they’re far more likely to stay.

In this blog, we’ll share 12 proven retention strategies. You’ll discover how to boost member engagement, increase renewal rates, and reduce churn with practical tactics, engagement best practices, and real-world examples from successful membership organisations.

Written by: Mark Camp | CEO & Founder Propello Cloud

 

 

Contents:

• Key Takeaways

• Why Does Membership Retention Matter?

• What Are the Key Challenges to Member Retention?

• How does the Member Journey Shape Retention?

• Which Metrics and KPIs should You Track to Measure Membership Retention Success

• What Retention Strategies Actually Work for Membership Organisations?

• What are the Benefits of Improving Membership Retention?

• How do you put your Retention Strategy into Action?

• Case Studies and Success Stories

• Now It’s Your Turn to Switch on Your Loyalty Growth Engine

• FAQs

 

Key Takeaways

	Retention is more cost-effective than acquisition. Consistency in communication, benefits, and experience keeps members engaged and loyal.
	Retention drives financial stability and long term value; members who stay renew more often, engage more deeply, and cost far less than constant acquisition.
	Shifting expectations, weak value propositions, and inconsistent engagement make retention harder than acquisition. Ignoring them accelerates churn.
	Mapping both the lifecycle and the value chain reveals where members need support and how rewards reinforce loyalty at every stage.
	Measuring retention, engagement, advocacy, and business impact gives a complete view of what’s working and where to improve.
	Successful organisations combine tactics like onboarding, personalisation, networking, and loyalty programmes to reduce churn and increase renewals.
	Stronger retention creates ripple effects: higher lifetime value, better advocacy, improved event ROI, and deeper emotional connection.
	Automating processes, segmenting members, enabling self-service, and keeping leaders visible turns strategy into day-to-day reality.
	Real-world results from ISM and Hagerty show how retention strategies increase engagement, strengthen value, and drive higher renewal rates

Propello is proud to be a MemberWise Recognised Supplier, trusted by leading membership organisations including NASUWT, The Ivors Academy, ISM, and the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh. Our white-label loyalty and reward platforms help membership bodies drive retention, boost member engagement, and deliver added value through personalised, benefit-led experiences.

Why Does Membership Retention Matter?

Membership retention is the ability of an organisation to keep members over time. It’s measured through your retention rate (the percentage of members who renew) and its opposite, the churn rate (the percentage who leave). High retention signals loyalty and stability, while high churn undermines growth.

Why does this matter so much? Retained members are more cost-effective than new acquisitions. Studies suggest it can be six to seven times cheaper to keep an existing member than recruit a new one. Strong retention also drives member lifetime value, as loyal members renew more often, engage more deeply, and contribute to long term sustainability. 

Ultimately, membership renewal underpins financial stability. Predictable renewals create a reliable revenue stream, giving organisations the confidence to invest in better benefits, events, and engagement strategies. Far from being just another metric, retention should be seen as the foundation of sustainable growth for any membership organisation.

From our research...

78% of membership organisations rank retention as a high priority. 20% name it as their single biggest priority.

How retention compares to other priorities:

* The primary focus for the organisation (organisations can have several high priorities)

Back to Contents

What Are the Key Challenges to Member Retention?

Membership retention may sound straightforward, but it’s often harder than acquisition. While campaigns can attract new members, keeping them engaged requires consistent value. Organisations today face shifting expectations, weak value propositions, and declining engagement at events. Let’s explore the main challenges that make retention such a critical yet difficult task.

Back to Contents

How does the Member Journey Shape Retention?

Successful reward programmes make the value of joining tangible from the very beginning. Members should feel incremental value and a sense of progression at every stage. This is why understanding the member journey is so important as it shapes how retention is built.

Typically, the journey follows the Member Lifecycle: acquisition → onboarding → engagement → renewal → loyalty. Alongside this, the Membership Value Chain offers another lens, showing how members can be rewarded at each stage to reinforce value and deepen loyalty.

Back to Contents

Which Metrics and KPIs should You Track to Measure Membership Retention Success?

To make sure your member reward programme is performing as intended, it’s important to track some essential metrics. These indicators will help you monitor membership retention, engagement, advocacy, and overall business impact. As your programme matures, you can expand the KPIs you track. But for now, these will see you through launch and early growth.

Net Promoter Score (NPS)*
Identify promoters, passives and detractors within in your memberbase using this question: 

“On a scale of 0 to 10, how likely are you to recommend [organisation/membership programme] to a friend or colleague?”

Members are then grouped based on their score:

Promoters (9–10): Very satisfied and likely to recommend.

Passives (7–8): Neutral — satisfied but not enthusiastic. 

Detractors (0–6): Unhappy members who may discourage others from joining.

Back to Contents

What Retention Strategies Actually Work for Membership Organisations?

Improving membership retention depends on more than a single tactic. The most successful organisations combine proven strategies that build trust, deliver consistent value, and strengthen connections across the member journey. From onboarding and engagement through to renewals and advocacy, these 12 strategies can help reduce churn and boost long term loyalty.

1) Do Premium Tiers Help to Improve Retention?  Creating clear, value-based tiers gives members room to grow with you. When needs change, an upgrade path (not a cancellation path) keeps them engaged and invested. In our report, 69% of organisations say introducing a higher tier/plan increased stickiness and organisational buy-in, turning “at-risk” members into advocates.

2) Do Loyalty & Rewards Programmes Really Increase Renewal? Well-designed loyalty programmes are proven to improve membership renewal rates. By offering timely, relevant rewards and recognising contributions, they create consistent value beyond core benefits. According to our report, 46% of organisations want programmes that use points, discounts, or recognition milestones that strengthen emotional connection and make renewal the natural choice.

3) How do Partnerships Increase Member Retention?  Strategic partnerships add high-impact benefits you don’t have to build yourself. Think accredited learning, CPD, and mentorship that directly advance members’ goals. Benefits they would otherwise pay more for elsewhere. Our data shows 41% of organisations see stronger buy-in and higher renewal where partnership-led benefits are front and centre, especially when credentials are co-branded and easy to redeem.

4) How Do Events & Community Drive Retention? Networking opportunities are a major reason people join membership organisations. Hosting mixers, mentoring programmes, or hybrid events helps members form valuable connections. 33% of membership organisations plan to use Events & Community as main retention drivers.  A calendar of regular, inclusive events keeps members active and invested in your community.

5) Why Does Onboarding Shape Long Term Loyalty? A smooth onboarding sets the tone for the entire journey. Confusing steps or vague communication cause disengagement early on. In our research, 28% of membership organisations said they plan to improve their onboarding process using personalised welcomes and communication of value to help new members feel supported from day one.

6) How Can Member Feedback Improve Retention? Member feedback is one of the most reliable ways to keep your organisation relevant. Surveys, polls, and exit interviews reveal what’s working and what isn’t. Acting on this insight builds trust and demonstrates transparency. A simple “you said, we did” approach helps members feel heard, valued, and more likely to stay engaged.

7) How Can Personalised Communication Build Stronger Communities? Generic messaging undermines connection. Personalised communication from tailored emails to event invitations that reflect member interests, makes individuals feel recognised. Coupled with community spaces for peer-to-peer connection, it deepens member engagement and reduces churn. Consistency is key: timely, relevant messages create trust and belonging.

8) How Does Exclusive Content Increase Retention? Exclusive content gives members something they can’t find elsewhere. Priority event booking, behind-the-scenes access, or professional development resources add value to your membership model and strengthen your value proposition. When members feel they’re receiving unique benefits, they’re more engaged, more satisfied, and more likely to renew.

9) How Do Membership Calendars Boost Engagement? An annual membership calendar helps maintain momentum. Planning seasonal campaigns, networking opportunities, and recognition moments ensures members stay active year-round. This consistency prevents long silences, avoids disengagement, and gives members a clear sense of progression. A predictable rhythm of activity strengthens both satisfaction and loyalty.

10) Why Should Content Be Regularly Refreshed? Static content leads to disengagement. Members want to see fresh resources, events, and offers that reflect their evolving needs. A continuous improvement loop — where you retire stale content and introduce new campaigns — signals that your organisation is dynamic and attentive, keeping members interested and invested over time.

11) Can Exclusive Member Perks Drive Everyday Engagement? Offering everyday value through partner discounts, savings, or lifestyle perks keeps your organisation top of mind beyond renewal season. Members who experience tangible value year-round are more satisfied, more active, and less likely to lapse.

12) How Do Referral Programmes Boost Both Retention and Acquisition? Referral programmes reward members for advocating on your behalf, turning loyalty into growth. Dual-sided rewards, where both the referrer and new member benefit, build fairness and trust. Recognising top referrers through leaderboards or spotlights further strengthens engagement, while helping you attract new members at a lower cost.

Back to Contents

What are the Benefits of Improving Membership Retention?

Strengthening membership retention creates a ripple effect of benefits across your organisation. When members stay longer, engage more often, and advocate on your behalf, the impact is felt everywhere. Here are some of the biggest benefits:

Improving retention is never just about keeping numbers steady. Membership organisations can build sustainable growth cycles, stronger communities and win hearts for years on end. 

Back to Contents

How do you put your Retention Strategy into Action?

A retention strategy only works if it’s embedded into day-to-day operations. That means making retention proactive instead of reactive, and using the right tools and practices to scale. Here are four practical ways to turn strategy into measurable results: 

Back to Contents

Case Studies and Success Stories

Retention strategies are most convincing when you see them in action. Below are two real-world examples of membership organisations that improved member engagement, increased renewal intent, and strengthened long-term loyalty by focusing on consistent value and personalisation.

How did ISM Improve Engagement and Renewals?

The Independent Society of Musicians (ISM) needed to increase engagement and make their benefits feel more relevant. By tailoring communications and offering everyday savings — such as discounts on groceries and dining — they improved perceived value. Real-time redemption data guided optimisation, helping ISM refine rewards and deliver more personalisation.

Outcome: ISM achieved 10x higher engagement, stronger perceived value, and greater intent to renew.

How did Hagerty strengthen Loyalty in a Competitive Market?

Hagerty Driving Club wanted to extend loyalty beyond insurance. They introduced VIP event access, exclusive content, and curated partner offers to build a more engaging experience. By integrating rewards into the renewal process, they made membership “stickier” while keeping engagement consistent across multiple touchpoints.

Outcome: Hagerty attracted 3,000 new members in the first year, achieved projected retention rates of 75%+ for HDC and 90% for insurance, and saw a marked increase in NPS.

Back to Contents

Now It’s Your Turn to Switch on Your Loyalty Growth Engine

Every membership organisation faces the same challenge: proving value in ways that keep members engaged, loyal, and renewing year after year. The strategies we’ve covered show that when retention is prioritised, it transforms from a defensive measure into a driver of sustainable growth.

The evidence is clear: better membership retention means lower churn, higher engagement, and stronger communities. Good retention is marked by maintained numbers. But with great retention strategies in place, your organisation can gain real momentum. Need help future-proofing your organisation, building loyalty, and unlocking long term member lifetime value? 

This comprehensive guide equips you with strategies for sustainable growth, covering member acquisition, engagement, and retention. Prepare to elevate your membership organisation's performance and deliver an exceptional member experience.

FAQs

1. Why is membership retention important?

Membership retention is important because retaining members is more cost effective than attracting new members. High retention rates reduce churn, increase loyalty, and create predictable revenue. For membership organisations, this stability supports long term growth and investment in better member benefits.

2. What is a good retention rate for membership organisations?

A strong retention rate varies by sector, but most membership organisations aim for 75–90%. The higher your retention, the more members stay loyal. Tracking churn rate alongside renewals gives a clearer picture of whether members feel engaged, valued, and supported over the long term.

3. How does the onboarding process affect member retention?

The onboarding process is critical for retention because it sets the tone for the member journey. A clear, personalised onboarding experience ensures members feel welcomed, supported, and aware of benefits. Weak onboarding increases churn risk before members fully engage with the membership model.

4. How can member feedback improve retention strategies?

Member feedback highlights what existing members value and where improvements are needed. Surveys, polls, and exit interviews help organisations refine benefits, communications, and events. Acting on feedback builds trust, making members feel heard and increasing loyalty, satisfaction, and renewal rates.

5. What role does member engagement play in retention?

Member engagement is the foundation of retention. Engaged members attend events, use rewards, and connect with the community. When members feel active and recognised, they’re more likely to stay. Low engagement signals dissatisfaction, often leading to higher churn and fewer membership renewals.

6. How can membership organisations reduce churn?

Membership organisations can reduce churn by offering consistent value, personalising communication, and providing relevant member benefits. Retention strategies like loyalty programmes, onboarding improvements, and feedback loops ensure members feel connected, supported, and motivated to renew long term.

7. What are cost-effective ways to retain members?

Cost-effective retention strategies include personalised communication, always-on partner discounts, referral programmes, and digital self-service. These approaches strengthen loyalty without heavy spending. Retaining members is far cheaper than attracting new members, making small consistent actions highly impactful.

8. How do membership renewals impact financial stability?
Membership renewals create predictable revenue streams that support financial stability. When members renew consistently, organisations can plan budgets, invest in engagement strategies, and deliver better benefits. Strong renewal rates signal loyalty, reduce acquisition costs, and underpin long term sustainability.

9. How does a sense of community influence retention?

A strong sense of community encourages members to stay engaged and loyal. Networking events, forums, and peer recognition make members feel valued and connected. Membership organisations that nurture belonging see higher engagement, stronger retention rates, and more advocacy from existing members.

10. What retention strategies work best long term?

The most effective long term retention strategies combine onboarding, member feedback, personalised communication, and loyalty programmes. These approaches strengthen value propositions, keep members engaged, and reduce churn. By investing in consistency, organisations build loyalty and improve member lifetime value.

Author Bio, Written By: 

Mark Camp | CEO & Founder at PropelloCloud.com | LinkedIn

Mark is the Founder and CEO of Propello Cloud, an innovative SaaS platform for loyalty and customer engagement. With over 20 years of marketing experience, he is passionate about helping brands boost retention and acquisition with scalable loyalty solutions.

Mark is an expert in loyalty and engagement strategy, having worked with major enterprise clients across industries to drive growth through rewards programmes. He leads Propello Cloud's mission to deliver versatile platforms that help organisations attract, engage and retain customers.