10 Reasons Why Loyalty Programmes Fail [+ Loyalty Programme Playbook]

In this article, I'll share critical insights on why loyalty programmes fail and, more importantly, how to avoid these pitfalls.

While loyalty programmes can dramatically transform customer retention and revenue, many fall short of their potential. The statistics paint a clear picture.

Just a small 5% increase in customer retention drives revenue growth anywhere between 25-95%.

Yet in spite of this, many programmes struggle to deliver results. The challenge lies in designing customer loyalty programmes that create genuine value for both your business and your customers.

Drawing from real market experience, we'll explore why loyalty programmes fail. We’ll look at strategic planning and customer experience design to reward structures and technical infrastructure. All of which make the difference between a merely functional programme to one that powers business growth.

Contents:

Key Takeaways
Key Challenges in Modern Loyalty Programmes
10 Crucial Loyalty Programme Mistakes to Avoid at all Costs

Future Considerations
Prioritise the Customer for the Best Results
FAQs

Playbook_Digital_Loyalty_Programme_CTA-1

Unlock the secrets to launching a successful digital loyalty & reward programme that drives customer retention and boosts your bottom line.

This comprehensive playbook will guide you through every step of developing, launching, and optimising a loyalty programme that resonates with your customers and delivers measurable results.

Gain exclusive access to a comprehensive template with step-by-step instructions for creating a digital programme.

Key Takeaways

Successful loyalty programmes demonstrate measurable impact - a 5% increase in customer retention can drive 25-95% revenue growth.
Modern customer behaviour demands more than transactional benefits. With consumers actively engaging in only half of their enrolled programmes, creating emotional connections through personalisation is crucial.
Programme design must balance sophistication with simplicity. While advanced loyalty mechanics drive engagement, complex user experiences create friction that discourages participation.
Technical infrastructure is fundamental to success. Over 80% of consumers prefer personalised experiences, making robust data management and real-time processing capabilities essential.
Effective reward structures must align with customer value. Research shows 33% of consumers leave even preferred brands when offered irrelevant rewards.
Gamification significantly impacts retention, with properly implemented game mechanics reducing customer attrition by 63%.

Key Challenges in Modern Loyalty Programmes

After speaking with hundreds of prospects, we've identified the main three challenges that modern loyalty programmes face. Ones they must address first to remain competitive in the present and deliver meaningful results for the future.

Let’s face it, enterprise organisations already face a difficult task justifying loyalty programme investments. But loyalty marketing continues to change as it responds to evolving customer behaviours, loyalty trends, and expectations around usability. Making delivering programme benefits that positively impacts customer retention all the more harder.

Evolution of Customer Behaviour

Today's consumers behave differently than they did just a few years ago. They expect immediate value, seamless experiences, and meaningful engagement across all touchpoints. Data shows that customer behaviour has shifted dramatically. Modern consumers belong to an average of 16 loyalty programmes, actively participating in only about half of them.

What's driving this selective engagement? We're seeing customers demand more than just transactional benefits. They're looking for emotional connections with brands, expecting personalised experiences that acknowledge their preferences.

Changing Loyalty Trends

Another shift in loyalty marketing is the move from purely transactional rewards to impactful engagement strategies. Programme success now depends on a combination of multi-dimensional value propositions and immediate benefits with longer-term relationship building.

Our work with enterprise clients shows that programmes with these elements see higher engagement rates and improved programme ROI. However, an issue arises when businesses fail to keep pace with changing loyalty trends. Long term engagement may prove impossible to achieve for businesses that do not know how to implement strategies such as gamification, effective communications, personalisation or simple reward redemption processes.

The challenges in maintaining engagement programmes creates a cycle where programmes fail to evolve with customer needs, leading to declining engagement and diminished returns on loyalty investments.

Balancing Programme Complexity and Usability

Striking the right balance between advanced loyalty mechanics and usability is tough. Which goes to show that designing customer loyalty programmes still persists as a conundrum for many businesses. From our experience implementing enterprise-level solutions, we've found that successful programme design follows three key principles:

Clear value proposition that customers easily understand.
Streamlined reward redemption processes that remove barriers to engagement and entry.
Flexible programme benefits that adapt to various customer segments.

The key is to maintain a simple, intuitive frontend experience. This improves engagement, collects more customer insights, and leads to personalisation without compromising user experience.

10 Crucial Loyalty Programme Mistakes to Avoid at All Costs

We've identified the following mistakes that can derail even well-designed loyalty programmes. Let's examine these pitfalls and their solutions in detail.

1) Setting unrealistic programme goals

The foundation of an unsuccessful loyalty programme often lies in unrealistic goals and objectives. While ambition drives innovation, your programme goals must be grounded in commercial reality. We've found the SMART framework particularly effective when properly adapted to loyalty initiatives.

For a loyalty programme, SMART goals should reflect both business objectives and customer value:

Specific - Define exactly what value you'll deliver to customers. For instance, "we will offer valuable rewards to customers engaged in a simple points-based transaction."
Measurable - Set concrete targets that you can track. A realistic example might be "increase customer sign-ups to our loyalty programme by 15-30%."
Attainable - Base targets on real data. We always recommend running pilot programmes - "recent tests on our pilot programme yielded a 15% minimum uptake on sign-ups."
Relevant - Connect programme goals to broader business outcomes. For example, "this goal will help generate net revenue retention (NRR) in the long term."
Time-based - Set clear deadlines for results. Be specific: "we aim to see results by the end of the second quarter."

The key is prioritising value and simplicity to create an engaging, frictionless customer experience. While your programme should incentivise engagement through elements like gamification and tiered rewards, these features must align with realistic, achievable goals.

Back to contents

2) Failure to communicate programmes effectively

Loyalty marketing naturally calls for effective and comprehensive communication strategies. While most businesses excel at announcing new initiatives, many struggle with ongoing programme communication. We see this manifest in three common ways:

First, information overload - bombarding customers with complex programme details that obscure the core value proposition.
Second, inconsistent messaging - where marketing doesn't accurately reflect the programme's benefits.
Third, insufficient promotion - often due to limited omnichannel support or restrictions from brand partners.

The solution lies in strategic, coordinated communication across your organisation. All promotions must align with your brand voice while accurately representing programme benefits. Marketing and sales teams need to work in harmony to deliver consistent messaging, and when collaborating with brand partners, the focus should be on communicating value rather than brand names.

Back to contents

3) Not being able to target specific demographics with relevant and engaging rewards

The rewards you offer determine your programme's success. The most effective rewards deliver real value aligned with customer needs. Many businesses make the mistake of selecting rewards based on operational convenience.

Availability, price, or ease of fulfilment but this approach inevitably leads to customer dissatisfaction.

Research shows that 33% of consumers will leave their favourite brands when offered irrelevant rewards and promotions.

A stark reminder that even strong brand loyalty is undermined by poor reward selection.

Instead, your reward strategy should prioritise your target audience's specific needs and preferences, moving beyond basic incentives to offer value outside your core products or services. Unique, choice-driven rewards encourage repeated engagement, personalisation builds emotional connections, and hyper-relevant offerings resonate with customers.

JD Sports Triggered Rewards

Solutions like Propello provide tailored rewards based on buyer behaviour and data insights.

Your customers get 24/7 access to a wealth of relevant partner deals and discounts to help increase customer retention and customer lifetime value.

Triggered rewards based on customer behaviour

Back to contents

4) Complicated programme structure

As I mentioned earlier, complex programme design creates friction that discourages engagement. Customers may hesitate to join programmes if it means navigating multiple pages just to redeem rewards.

Simple user experience coupled with sophisticated capabilities behind the scenes remains a winning formula. Just make sure to:

Make reward balance checking and redemption straightforward.
Capture essential user data with easy sign-up processes.
Provide clear guidelines for claiming and reviewing rewards.
Enable members to easily explain the programme to others.

Back to contents

5) Unrealistic targets for customers to redeem rewards

While developing unique loyalty schemes is admirable, setting overly ambitious redemption thresholds is a common pitfall.

When members feel they're not receiving enough value for their participation, or rewards take too long, up to 78% will abandon the programme, and customer engagement suffers as a result.

Your targets should balance attainability with business objectives. This means:

Setting clear, achievable milestones for reward redemption.
Creating a smooth redemption process that enhances the customer experience.
Structuring rewards to recognise and encourage specific behaviours.
Offering appropriate incentives for different levels of engagement.

For example, providing free shipping after a certain number of purchases creates an attainable goal while encouraging repeat transactions. Make rewards valuable enough to motivate engagement whilst keeping them commercially viable.

Back to contents

6) Overemphasising corporate goals

A heavy focus on business metrics loses sight of customer value. The most successful loyalty programmes create mutual benefit. They deliver clear value to customers and achieve business objectives by doing so. When organisations prioritise their goals over customer benefits, it’ll quickly become apparent.

Remember the research I cited earlier, showing that while consumers belong to an average of 16 loyalty programmes, they actively engage with only half of them? This disengagement often stems from low-quality incentives.

Studies show that 71% of consumers are turned off by what they deem low-quality rewards.

Back to contents

7) Choosing the wrong type of loyalty programme

Consider your programme type carefully too. Programme selection should be driven by a deep understanding of your business model, customers’ behaviour, and operational capabilities. Different loyalty schemes build trust and drive engagement in unique ways. Through our experience, we've identified clear patterns in programme effectiveness:

Your choice should be informed by thorough analysis of your:

Target demographic preferences and behaviours.
Business model and revenue patterns.
Product or service characteristics.
Customer purchase frequency and value.
Operational capabilities and resources.

Don’t get me wrong, points-based systems work well but only if they are easy for customers to track points and redeem rewards. Alternatively, instant reward programmes provide immediate value through constant incentives, often funded by strategic brand partnerships, eliminating the need for complex point calculations.

Download our guide to help you discover which is the best loyalty programme for your business based on industry, demographics and other crucial criteria:

Back to contents

8) Outdated technology to support programmes

Programme success depends on robust technical capabilities. Modern loyalty initiatives require sophisticated data management, real-time processing, and seamless integration across channels.

Data shows that over 80% of consumers prefer brands offering personalised experiences

yet many organisations struggle with legacy systems that limit their ability to deliver this.

Key technical requirements for modern loyalty programmes include:

Scalable white-label technology for rapid deployment.
Comprehensive data collection and analysis capabilities.
Real-time reporting and performance tracking.
Advanced personalisation capabilities.
Seamless integration with existing systems.

Without proper technical infrastructure, you'll struggle to gather and act on customer insights that drive acutely effective programme optimisation. For instance, in tiered programmes, data often reveals when customers find tier progression too challenging or rewards insufficient to motivate advancement.

Back to contents

9) Not recognising potential of gamification

Gamification represents one of the most powerful tools for driving customer engagement in modern loyalty initiatives. I think it’s important to highlight gamification as it’s perhaps one of, if not, the most important engagement strategies.

Quality service is important, winning experiences create memorable engagement that drives lasting loyalty after all.

Yet brands that implement gamified elements experience 63% lower customer attrition rates.

That’s not to say implement gamification at the expense of quality service. Master the basics first but as you graduate towards more advanced strategies, make gamification one of them!

Effective gamification takes many forms:

Interactive challenges and competitions.
Progress tracking and achievement systems.
Social elements and community features.
Reward multipliers and bonus opportunities.
Special events and limited-time promotions.

These mechanics also reinforce positive behavioural change and eventually create brand advocates.

Gamification in loyalty programmes

Back to contents

10) Failing to Differentiate Customer Value

While consistent service is essential, avoid a one-size-fits-all approach as it undermines programme effectiveness. Balance fair treatment with value-based differentiation. Our approach advocates two fundamental principles:

First, maintain consistent service quality across all customer segments - whether they're first-time buyers or loyal members.
Second, implement tiered rewards that scale with customer value, offering increasingly meaningful benefits to your most valuable customers.

Remember that premium benefits don't necessarily require higher costs. Early access to sales, exclusive product previews, and priority service create perceived value without substantial operational expense. The goal is recognising and rewarding customer loyalty in ways that drive both satisfaction and business growth.

Back to contents

Future Considerations

The loyalty landscape is rapidly evolving, driven by technological advancement and shifting consumer expectations. To build sustainable loyalty programmes, organisations must anticipate and adapt to emerging trends while maintaining focus on fundamental value creation.

Emerging Loyalty Marketing strategies

The future of loyalty marketing extends far beyond traditional points and rewards. Customers expect intelligence-driven engagement strategies that create deeper customer relationships:

AI-Powered Personalisation: Advanced algorithms are enabling hyper-personalised experiences, predicting customer needs and tailoring rewards in real-time. This goes beyond basic segmentation to create truly individualised customer experiences.
Zero-Party Data Strategies: With increasing privacy concerns, successful programmes will prioritise transparent data collection, where customers willingly share preferences in exchange for clear value.
Cross-Brand Ecosystems: Strategic partnerships are evolving into comprehensive lifestyle ecosystems. Rather than isolated rewards, customers gain access to interconnected benefits across complementary brands.
Subscription-Based Loyalty: The rise of premium loyalty programmes, where members pay for enhanced benefits, is reshaping how brands monetise loyalty while delivering exceptional value.