Today, I’ll discuss how membership organisations can craft an effective member value proposition, which helps to increase acquisition, retention, engagement and growth.
We'll look at:
-
How to align your value proposition with your organisation's mission and make it member-centric.
-
Benefits of a clear member value proposition.
-
Segmentation of your audience to make your value proposition granular but relevant to various demographics.
-
Examples of organisations with compelling value propositions and more.
At the end you’ll have all the information you need to create a compelling new value proposition or sharpen your existing one
Contents:
Key Takeaways
-
A strong member value proposition (MVP) is crucial for driving engagement, acquisition, and retention.
-
Align your MVP with your organisation's mission for authenticity and impact.
-
Personalisation is key: 71% of consumers expect personalised experiences.
-
Segment your audience to tailor benefits and communication effectively.
-
Key components of a strong MVP include clear benefits, relevance, exclusivity, community, and growth opportunities.
-
Effective communication of your MVP across all touchpoints is essential for success.
-
Regularly test and iterate your MVP to keep it relevant and effective.
-
Implement your MVP across the entire membership lifecycle, from acquisition to retention.
-
Learn from successful case studies to inspire your own MVP strategy.
-
Use data and member feedback to continuously improve your value proposition.
Understanding Value Propositions
A value proposition articulates your organisation’s unique benefits and offerings. It’s a commitment to serving value that you promised to existing and potential members. In the case of membership organisations, value propositions are closely tied to their mission. Clearly communicating your mission matters as it sets the stage for stronger relationships with members.
"People are motivated both by values they hold and by rewards. Your membership value proposition will draw on value motivations when you appeal to a higher purpose
Your membership value proposition will draw on rewards when you articulate how your programme will fulfil that motivation (e.g.“gain access to exclusive content”). Powerful membership-driven organisations use their value proposition to draw on both values and rewards"
Source: The Membership Guide
Benefits of a Clear Member Value Proposition
A compelling member value proposition is essential for driving engagement, acquisition, and retention. By offering relevant, personalised, and rewarding experiences, your membership organisation can encourage members to interact more frequently and develop a stronger connection with you.
Boosts member acquisition
Clear and attractive value propositions communicate the benefits of membership, such as enticing incentives. In addition to this, simplifying the enrollment process also helps attract new members. Smooth onboarding improves perceived value because it associates your organisation with convenience. Plus, it gives good first impressions.
Increases member retention rates
Retaining members requires consistently delivering value and creating a sense of belonging. This can be achieved through tiered benefits, exclusive experiences, personalised communication, and flexible options that cater to individual preferences. Making members feel valued and appreciated leads the way towards long-term loyalty and reduced member churn.
Drives member engagement and loyalty
A compelling value proposition is key to driving engagement and loyalty. When members clearly see the benefits they're getting, they're more likely to actively participate in your organisation's activities. This could mean higher attendance at events, more frequent use of resources, or increased interaction in online communities.
Engaged members tend to be more loyal. They see the ongoing value in their membership and are less likely to let it lapse. This engagement also often translates into member advocacy - satisfied members become your best marketers, recommending your organisation to others in their network.
Impact on membership growth
A clear value proposition can significantly boost membership growth. It makes your organisation more attractive to potential members by clearly articulating the benefits of joining. This clarity can be a powerful tool in member acquisition strategies.
Moreover, when existing members understand and appreciate the value they're receiving, they're more likely to renew their memberships. This improved retention, combined with easier acquisition, can lead to substantial membership growth over time. A strong value proposition thus becomes a cornerstone of sustainable organisational expansion.
Aligning Your Value Proposition to Your Organisational Mission
The core mission of your organisation is its heart and soul. The centrepiece of everything and the reason it exists. I’ve already touched on this in Understanding Value Propositions. But I can’t stress enough how important it is that your value proposition aligns with your organisation’s mission.
Your value proposition is not just a marketing tool; it's a promise you're genuinely dedicated to delivering. That's why mission-aligned value propositions are often more successful. They are a statement to members that you're committed to achieving the mission’s success. This reinforces your organisation's identity, helping you to mark out its own unique persona in competitive landscapes.
Identifying your unique selling points
When it comes to your value proposition, uniqueness is key. It's about pinpointing what sets you apart in a crowded field. In my experience, this often comes down to your organisation's specific expertise, resources, or approach.
Start by looking at your strengths. What do you do better than anyone else? Maybe it's your cutting-edge research, your extensive network, or your innovative member services. These are the gems that make your organisation stand out.
Don't forget to consider your members' perspectives. What do they value most about your organisation? Their insights can reveal unique selling points you might have overlooked.
Clearly defining the problems you're solving for members
At its core, your value proposition should address real problems your members face. It's not just about offering benefits; it's about providing solutions.
Take a deep dive into your members' challenges. Are they struggling with professional development? Seeking networking opportunities? Looking for ways to stay ahead in a rapidly changing industry?
By clearly articulating these problems and how you solve them, you make your value proposition more compelling and relevant. It shows members you understand their needs and have the tools to help them succeed.
5 key questions to ask when defining your MVP
When crafting your Member Value Proposition (MVP), asking the right questions is crucial. Here are five I always recommend repurposed for this blog:
-
What tangible benefits do we offer that members can't easily get elsewhere?
-
How does our offering align with our members' goals and challenges?
-
What emotional or aspirational value do we provide beyond practical benefits?
-
How does our value proposition differentiate us from competitors?
-
Is our value proposition clear, concise, and easy for potential members to understand?
Answering these questions honestly will help you refine your MVP, ensuring it's both compelling and true to your organisation's mission.
Member-centric Value Propositions
A one-size-fits-all approach no longer suffices in the diverse world of membership organisations. Members, customers, all different types of consumers for that matter, expect personalised experiences.
In fact, personalisation is now expected by 71% of consumers.
Weaving a member-centric philosophy into your value proposition increases the appeal of your organisation. Doing so increases the relevance of benefits to the unique needs and preferences of potential members.
Segmenting Your Members
Segmenting members allows organisations to address the diverse needs, preferences, and expectations of their audience. Understanding these unique characteristics allows your organisation to fine-tune its value proposition and product or service. You’ll have more insights into which member benefits resonate the most with your target audience.
Adopting a tailored and personalised approach to the membership experience strengthens your value proposition. A value proposition fine-tuned to specific demographics resonates with their high expectations. Therefore, tailoring added value and tangible benefits to different segments results in a more responsive and content membership base.
Recognising the unique needs and preferences of your members makes your messaging and service much more relevant to them. Many organisations and associations are suffering low retention and acquisition rates. This is mainly due to changing expectations, such as interactive, engaging and value-driven online experiences.
Problem is, from prospective clients and my own research, my team and I have found that most organisations are behind on tech innovation. Legacy tech holds many back in spite of widespread agreement in the industry that members desire a digital overhaul.
Personalising benefits to enhance member satisfaction
Personalising benefits is crucial for boosting member satisfaction. It's about understanding individual member needs and tailoring your offerings accordingly.
Leverage your member data to identify engagement patterns and preferred benefits. Use this insight to create a tiered benefit system, allowing members to choose their ideal level of engagement.
Personalised communication is key. Send targeted updates about relevant benefits to show you understand each member's unique needs. This approach increases use of benefit and demonstrates value.
Remember, personalisation extends beyond tangible benefits. Customised paths for professional development, networking, and industry knowledge align with individual goals, facilitating member success. Personalising benefits will see improved satisfaction, better retention rates, and increased member advocacy - driving both loyalty and growth.
Key Components of a Strong Member Value Proposition
A robust member value proposition is built on several key pillars. In my experience, these components work together to create a compelling offer that attracts and retains members. I’ve already mentioned some of these. Here, I’ll show you how to put them into action.
-
Clear benefits: Articulate tangible and intangible advantages of membership.
-
Relevance: Align offerings with member needs and industry trends.
-
Exclusivity: Provide unique opportunities unavailable elsewhere.
-
Community: Foster a sense of belonging and professional network.
-
Growth: Offer pathways for personal and professional development.
These elements form the foundation of a value proposition that resonates with members and drives organisational success.
Added Value for Your Members
- Loyalty & Reward Programmes: Excellent tools for improving member loyalty, advocacy, and member engagement. With member reward programmes, small and medium organisations can significantly increase engagement by offering exclusive rewards and privileges.
- Customised Learning Resources & Educational Content: Develop educational materials, webinars, courses, or workshops relevant to the industry or sector that members operate within. For instance, a professional association might offer industry-specific training, certifications or guides.
- Access to Exclusive Knowledge: Offer members special access to content such as research papers, case studies or reports. This unique access to valuable information enhances the members' expertise and competence in their field.
- Tailored Educational Tracks: Offer learning paths customised to different member segments, levels of experience or areas of interest. For instance, beginner, intermediate, and advanced learning modules cater to members with varying expertise levels.
- Tailored Events: Organise events, seminars, workshops, or webinars that cater to different members’ interests and career stages. This could include both general networking sessions and specific educational forums.
- Interactive Platforms: Create platforms for members to interact, share knowledge, and network online. Forums, discussion boards, or online events can be valuable additions to in-person events, serving as year-round networking opportunities.
With a personalised rewards experience and customised educational content, and targeted networking and learning events, your membership organisation can create a compelling value proposition. This tailored approach enhances the relevance and attractiveness of membership, increasing member satisfaction and loyalty.
Exclusive access and opportunities
Offer priority access or discounts for members to attend these events. Ensure the content and speakers are highly relevant and beneficial to the members' professional or personal development. This will make your events stand out even more and increase your value proposition further.
Networking and community building
Networking and community building are cornerstones of a strong member value proposition. They create a sense of belonging that goes beyond transactional benefits.
Facilitate both formal and informal networking opportunities. This could include mentorship programmes, special interest groups, or online forums. These platforms allow members to share knowledge, collaborate on projects, and build lasting professional relationships.
Remember, community isn't just about professional connections. It's about creating a shared identity and purpose. Encourage member-led initiatives and celebrate collective achievements. This fosters a sense of ownership and pride in the community.
Leverage technology to extend networking beyond physical events. Online platforms can facilitate year-round engagement, allowing members to connect regardless of location or time constraints.
Professional development and industry knowledge
Professional development and industry knowledge are key drivers of member value. They position your organisation as a catalyst for career growth and success.
Offer a diverse range of learning opportunities. This could include workshops, webinars, certifications, or access to industry experts. Tailor these offerings to different career stages and specialisations within your field.
Stay ahead of industry trends and provide cutting-edge insights and forecasts that help members navigate their professional landscape. This positions your organisation as a thought leader and indispensable resource.
Consider partnerships with educational institutions or other industry bodies to enhance your professional development offerings. This can provide members with unique learning opportunities and credentials.
Communicating Your Member Value Proposition
I've found that even the most compelling value propositions fall flat if not communicated properly. It's not just about what you offer, but how you convey it to your members and potential members. Here’s some of my ideas for effectively communicating a member value proposition:
Crafting a compelling MVP statement
Your Member Value Proposition (MVP) statement is your elevator pitch. It needs to be clear, concise, and compelling. Here's my approach:
-
Start with the problem you're solving for members.
-
Briefly outline your unique solution.
-
Highlight the key benefits members will experience.
-
End with a strong emotional appeal or call-to-action.
Remember, your MVP statement should resonate with your target audience. Use language that speaks directly to their needs and aspirations.
Effective strategies for value communication
Communicating value isn't a one-and-done deal. It's an ongoing process that requires consistent effort and multiple touchpoints:
-
Use storytelling: Share member success stories that illustrate the tangible benefits of your value proposition.
-
Leverage data: Use metrics and statistics to back up your claims and demonstrate ROI for members.
-
Personalise your messaging: Tailor your communication to different member segments like I showed you how earlier, addressing their specific needs and interests.
-
Be transparent: Clearly explain how members can access and maximise the benefits you're offering.
Showcasing your MVP across various platforms and touchpoints
Your value proposition should be evident at every interaction a member or potential member has with your organisation:
-
Website: Feature your MVP prominently on your homepage and dedicated 'Benefits' pages.
-
Email marketing: Regularly remind members of the value they're receiving and highlight new benefits.
-
Social media: Use these platforms to showcase member testimonials and highlight unique aspects of your value proposition.
-
Events: Ensure that your events reflect and reinforce your value proposition.
-
Member onboarding: Make your MVP a central part of your welcome process for new members.
Clear, consistent, and targeted communication around your MVP rounds it off perfectly, driving both acquisition and retention.
Case Studies
In this section, I’m sharing four brief case studies of membership organisations with strong value propositions. These are Unison, the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB), University of the Third Age and our client the Independent Society of Music (ISM).
Unison
Unison is a UK union for public service workers, improving pay and working conditions through negotiations. Unison was established in 1993 to safeguard workers' rights in various sectors like local government, education, and healthcare.
People are at the centre of Unison’s interest and it clearly shows in their value proposition. Members get access to professional support and advice and qualified legal representation. What truly stands out is the range of benefits for members. These vary from:
-
Great mortgage and home insurance deals.
-
A rewards scheme that gives cash back when shopping at selected retailers.
-
Exclusive travel deals (including Unison’s own resort!).
-
Superb motoring deals e.g., discounts on Vauxhalls, insurance and breakdown cover.
-
Eyecare vouchers, life and dentist insurance.
-
Access to courses, either free or subsidised to help brighten the career prospects of members.
Unison’s value proposition lies in going beyond the expectations of their members. Legal representation for underrepresented people, is in itself a fantastic benefit for joining as a member. But it’s Unison’s regard for its members as people that truly sets it apart.
Unison provides support for all aspects of members' lives, including home, health, travel, career, family, and shopping needs.
Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)
The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds or the RSPB was founded in 1889. Their mission is to protect and preserve birds and their habitats in the UK. They achieve this through various actions. Restoring habitats, campaigning, conducting research and monitoring bird populations, just to name a few.
One of the most striking aspects of their value proposition is the educational content available on the website. This is a great touch as it offers everyone who visits practical steps to care for birds. Increasing the chance of what may start as a budding interest in protecting birds becoming a lifelong mission.
If you can weave an opportunity for newcomers to participate, chances are they will!
Where the RSPB delivers a truly compelling value proposition is on their What’s Happening and Days Out pages. Including regularly updated newsletters, events open to both members and non-members, and competitions to win special prizes.
Members also receive free access to any of their 70 bird reserves located across the country. This is a powerful member benefit as it aligns with their interest and passion for protecting UK wildlife.
University of the Third Age
An international organisation that offers fantastic educational and social opportunities, the University of the Third Age offers retired or semi-retired individuals a platform for lifelong learning. Members are able to share their knowledge, interests and skills in a friendly community of like minded individuals.
The U3A is a prime example of organisations building a solid community. They pride themselves on bringing people together. Whether that’s out of a shared love for a particular academic subject or a passion for the creative field. Members can get together to discuss history, write poetry or create art; there’s something for every member.
Is that the value proposition? I’d say so. What’s more member-centric than making other people the reason to sign up to your organisation? The U3A has blossomed around three core principles. What’s more, visitors to the website get a free toolkit in addition to:
-
A radio podcast.
-
Subject-centric interest groups that foster a sense of community.
-
Writing competitions.
-
Gamification.
-
Days out and visits to historical locations and other locations of interest.
-
Even U3A's very own festival!
Members have access to a three day festival in York in 2024. Special invites to events like these are strong incentives for new people to join.
Independent Society of Music (ISM)
The Independent Society of Musicians (ISM), the UK's largest non-unionised community of musicians, has been championing musicians' rights since 1882. Recognising the need to evolve their member benefits programme, ISM partnered with us at Propello to revolutionise their member value proposition.
By implementing our next-gen engagement and loyalty solution, ISM achieved:
-
Significant uplift in programme updates and rewards redemption
-
Real-time data insights for continual improvement
-
A diverse range of benefits beyond music-related perks
The standout feature, ISM Discount+ scheme, offers savings on everyday essentials, recognising members' diverse needs. As one member testified:
"Over the course of a year, the money I save is greater than the cost of my ISM membership."
ISM's success demonstrates the power of a well-crafted, member-centric value proposition. By focusing on relevance, personalisation, and tangible benefits, they've boosted engagement and reinforced their indispensable role for UK musicians.
Testing and Iteration
Try avoiding setting your value proposition in stone. It should evolve alongside your organisation and its members. You can achieve this by regularly testing and refining your value proposition. Moreover, it allows for a dynamic approach in crafting your value proposition, always remaining relevant to the needs and preferences of your members.
A framework for continuous value proposition improvement
Your framework should collect member feedback and analyse data to improve messaging and value-added benefits. Actively seeking and acting on member feedback greatly improves the value proposition of your membership organisation. This involves:
Feedback surveys and suggestions: Regularly conduct surveys or feedback sessions to understand what members seek from the organisation. Analyse the feedback and use it to tailor your value proposition for potentially new members too.
Personalised benefits: Use the feedback received to personalise benefits and services for different member segments. For example, tailor offerings to groups that express interest in specific types of events or resources.
Continuous improvements: Consistently improve services and benefits based on member feedback. Demonstrating a willingness to evolve in response to member needs significantly increases satisfaction and loyalty.
Implementing Your MVP Across the Membership Lifecycle
So now we know a strong Member Value Proposition (MVP) isn't just a marketing tool but a backbone of your entire membership strategy, it’s time to break down how to deploy your MVP at each stage of the membership lifecycle.
Leveraging your MVP in member acquisition strategies
Your MVP should be front and centre in your acquisition efforts. Use it to create compelling marketing messages that resonate with potential members. Highlight the unique benefits and value you offer, and how they address specific pain points in your industry.
Using your MVP to enhance the member onboarding experience
Once a member joins, your seamless onboarding process should reinforce the value proposition that attracted them in the first place. Create a structured onboarding journey that introduces new members to each aspect of your MVP.
Consider creating a 'quick wins' programme that helps new members immediately access high-value benefits. This could be instant access to a members-only resource library or an invitation to an exclusive event. The goal is to demonstrate value from day one.
Reinforcing your MVP throughout the member journey
Keep your MVP at the forefront of your ongoing member communications. Regularly highlight different aspects of your value proposition in newsletters, member updates, and across your digital platforms.
We've seen great success with 'benefit of the month' campaigns that deep-dive into a specific aspect of your MVP. This keeps your value proposition fresh and ensures members are aware of the full range of benefits available to them.
Applying your MVP in retention and renewal efforts
Since your MVP should evolve with your members' needs, there is a need for renewal campaigns. In these renewal campaigns, remind members of the value they've received. Personalised 'year in review' communications that highlight how a member has benefited from their membership are also powerful retention tools.
Make Members an Offer They Can't Refuse
An effective member value proposition should align with your mission and be member-centric. Segmenting your target audience and tailoring your value proposition to different demographics makes it member-centric. Membership benefits and incentives that match members' interests and passions are crucial, as shown in the case studies. Always set out to test and retest your approach and build a framework that allows for continuous improvement.
It's a good idea to keep track of membership trends so any new ideas relevant to your membership base can be factored into strengthening your member value proposition.
Should you want to improve member retention and engagement, check out our helpful guide below the FAQs.
This guide provides valuable tips and strategies to make it easier for you to keep members and get them more involved. Enhance your value proposition even more by following the advice in the guide.
FAQs
What is a member value proposition (MVP)?
A member value proposition (MVP) is a clear statement of the tangible and intangible benefits an organisation offers its members. It articulates the unique value members receive in exchange for their commitment.
How does a strong MVP impact member retention?
A strong MVP significantly improves member retention by consistently delivering value and creating a sense of belonging. It offers personalised benefits, exclusive experiences, and targeted communication that cater to individual preferences.
What are the key components of an effective member value proposition?
1) Clear benefits that articulate tangible and intangible advantages
2) Relevance to member needs and industry trends
3) Exclusivity through unique opportunities
4) Community fostering a sense of belonging
5) Growth pathways for personal and professional development.
How can organisations personalise their MVP for different member segments?
Organisations can personalise their MVP by segmenting their membership base and tailoring benefits to each group's needs. This involves analysing member data to identify preferences, creating tiered benefit systems, and offering customised learning paths.
What role does technology play in implementing a strong MVP?
Technology plays a crucial role in implementing a strong MVP by enabling personalisation, data analysis, and seamless member experiences. It facilitates real-time tracking of member engagement, allows for targeted communication, and supports interactive platforms for networking and knowledge sharing.
How often should an organisation review and update its MVP?
Organisations should regularly review and update their MVP to ensure it remains relevant and effective. A good practice is to conduct a thorough review annually, with ongoing monitoring and minor adjustments throughout the year. This approach allows for continuous improvement based on member feedback.
What are some effective strategies for communicating an MVP to members?
1) Crafting a clear, concise MVP statement
2) Using storytelling to illustrate benefits
3) Leveraging data to demonstrate ROI
4) Personalising messaging for different member segments
5) Ensuring consistency across all platforms
6) Incorporating the MVP into onboarding processes.
How can organisations measure the effectiveness of their MVP?
Organisations can measure MVP effectiveness through key metrics such as member acquisition rates, retention rates, engagement levels, and overall membership growth. Conducting regular member surveys, analysing feedback, and tracking benefit utilisation provide valuable insights.
What are some common challenges in implementing an MVP, and how can they be overcome
Common MVP implementation challenges include gaining organisational buy-in, balancing diverse member needs, and overcoming outdated systems. These can be addressed by involving stakeholders in MVP development, using member segmentation for targeted value delivery and investing in technology.
How can small organisations with limited resources create a compelling MVP?
Small organisations can create compelling MVPs by focusing on their unique strengths and member needs. They can leverage partnerships for expanded benefits, use cost-effective technology for personalisation, and emphasise community-building.
Mark Camp | CEO & Founder at PropelloCloud.com | LinkedIn
Mark is the Founder and CEO of Propello Cloud, an innovative SaaS platform for loyalty and customer engagement. With over 20 years of marketing experience, he is passionate about helping brands boost retention and acquisition with scalable loyalty solutions.
Mark is an expert in loyalty and engagement strategy, having worked with major enterprise clients across industries to drive growth through rewards programmes. He leads Propello Cloud's mission to deliver versatile platforms that help organisations attract, engage and retain customers.
.png){kind=logo}